Notes

Startup Counsel

We Incorporated. Did We Actually Issue the Founders’ Shares?

What a Delaware startup can show its first investor when the cap table lists both founders and one stock purchase agreement is missing.

Founder Equity / Cap Tables / Governance

Say two founders agree to split their Delaware corporation 50/50. They file a charter authorizing 10 million shares of common stock, put four million next to each name on the cap table, and get back to building the product.

A few months later, a seed investor asks for the documents showing when each founder bought those shares. What would the company send?

The charter tells you how many shares the company can issue. If the company issued four million shares to each founder and has never issued any others, each founder owns half. Two million shares remain authorized and unissued. To see whether that math describes this company, follow the first eight million shares through its records. Delaware General Corporation Law § 102(a)(4) and § 152.

Read what the board approved

I’d start with the initial board consent. Suppose it authorizes the company to sell four million shares to each founder once that founder signs a stock purchase agreement and pays the stated price. One board consent can cover both sales. Now follow each purchase separately.

For one founder, the company has a signed agreement and a matching deposit. For the other, the e-signature record ends at “sent.” Both names appear on the spreadsheet. Before confirming that the second purchase closed, look for a copy signed elsewhere and evidence that the company received that founder’s payment.

The approval tells you what evidence to look for. If the board agreed to take pre-incorporation code in exchange for stock, find the signed assignment covering that code. Then check the names, share counts, and dates against the company’s stock ledger. The ledger can be electronic, and the board can authorize uncertificated shares by resolution. Delaware General Corporation Law § 158, § 219(c), and § 224.

Figure out what needs fixing

A missing copy and a missed issuance call for different work. If both purchases closed, recover the records and correct the ledger where needed. If a purchase never closed, company counsel can work out the terms and approvals for an issuance now. An earlier attempt to issue stock with a defective approval may qualify for ratification under Delaware law. In each case, record when people actually acted, including when they sign any corrective documents. Delaware General Corporation Law § 204.

A founder can buy stock up front while the company retains the right to repurchase the unvested shares if the founder leaves. For restricted stock transferred in connection with services, a founder who wants to make a Section 83(b) election generally has 30 days after the transfer to file it with the IRS. If the records don’t establish when the shares were transferred, the founder should raise that question with their own tax adviser promptly. Internal Revenue Code § 83(b) and IRS filing instructions.

Before sending a cap table to a first investor, pull the documents behind each founder’s row. An unsigned agreement is easier to investigate while both founders still work together, remember what they signed, and can find the payment records.

Startup formation and early-stage company counsel

Dealing with a similar issue? Get in touch.