Notes

Deal Notes

Your Cap Table Is Not Enough

Startup financing diligence is a recordkeeping test. The cap table only matters if the company can prove the documents behind it.

Jason Gershenson/ Financing diligence/ Cap tables/ Recordkeeping

A startup's cap table is only as reliable as the documents behind it.

That becomes obvious during a financing. Investors and company counsel need to confirm not just who owns what, but why they own it, what rights they have, and whether the company can prove it.

"We have a cap table" is not the same as "we are ready for diligence."

What diligence is really testing

Financing diligence is often described as a review of corporate records. In practice, it is a test of whether the company's legal history can be reconstructed without guesswork.

Counsel may need to confirm:

  • who purchased securities
  • what they purchased
  • when they purchased it
  • whether the documents were signed
  • whether signatures were complete and authorized
  • whether side letters changed the economics or rights
  • whether the cap table matches the charter and approvals
  • whether old platforms, spreadsheets, and closing folders tell the same story

If those pieces do not line up, the financing can slow down for reasons that have nothing to do with the business.

The cap table is the summary, not the evidence

A cap table summarizes ownership. It does not prove ownership by itself.

The underlying record may include:

  • stock purchase agreements
  • SAFE agreements
  • side letters
  • board approvals
  • stockholder approvals
  • option grant approvals
  • exercise documents
  • transfer documents
  • charter filings
  • investor rights agreements
  • management rights letters
  • disclosure schedules

The company should be able to move from the cap table to the source documents without scrambling.

Where records break down

The problems are usually mundane. That is why they get ignored.

Common diligence gaps include:

  • missing fully executed copies
  • inconsistent investor names
  • fund entities that do not match signature blocks
  • rollover vehicles or nominee entities that are not mapped
  • side letters saved outside the closing folder
  • SAFEs listed on the cap table without related pro rata letters
  • platform records that do not match signed documents
  • option grants approved but not documented cleanly
  • disclosure schedules that rely on stale ownership information

None of this is glamorous. But in a live financing, boring record problems can become closing problems.

Investor names and signature blocks matter

Fund names are easy to get slightly wrong. The contracting party may be a fund, a parallel fund, a special purpose vehicle, a nominee, a general partner, or an affiliate. The cap table may use a shorthand name that is fine internally but not precise enough for closing documents.

That matters when the company has to prepare schedules, consents, side-letter amendments, notices, and signature packets.

If the company cannot tell who holds the right, it may not know who must sign the waiver.

Platform migrations do not solve document problems

Moving from one equity platform to another can make administration cleaner. It does not fix the historical record by itself.

Before relying on a migrated cap table, the company should reconcile:

  • investor names
  • security types
  • purchase amounts
  • issuance dates
  • certificate or book-entry records
  • SAFE and note terms
  • option plan records
  • side-letter rights
  • board and stockholder approvals

The system is useful only if the source data is right.

Practical preparation before financing diligence

Before a serious financing process, the company should:

  • collect every financing document and side letter
  • confirm fully executed copies
  • create a holder schedule that matches the cap table
  • map legal names to display names used in the cap table
  • identify every pro rata, MFN, information, and management right
  • reconcile option grants against board approvals
  • confirm charter filings and amendments
  • build a clean data room organized by transaction
  • fix gaps before investors are waiting on answers

Recordkeeping is not a back-office issue when the company is raising money. It is part of the financing story.

The companies that close efficiently are usually not the companies with no complexity. They are the companies that can explain their complexity with documents.