Venture Financings
Our First Investor Sent a SAFE. How Much of the Company Are We Selling?
A $250,000 check at a $5 million cap sounds like a 5% decision. What happens if the company needs to raise $1 million?
SAFEs / Cap Tables / Startups
An investor offers $250,000 and sends over a SAFE with a $5 million post-money valuation cap. Your cofounder wants to sign. The money would let you hire the engineer you need to get the product into a customer’s hands.
On those terms, 5% sounds reasonable. The question I’d ask before signing is how much money it takes to find out whether that customer will pay.
Price the whole raise
Suppose your budget calls for $1 million. The investor sent Y Combinator’s U.S. post-money SAFE with a valuation cap and no discount. A SAFE is a simple agreement for future equity. The investor pays now and receives shares if the SAFE converts in a priced financing.
If the cap sets the conversion price, the first check works out to roughly 5% just before the new investors buy their shares. That’s $250,000 divided by $5 million. Take the full $1 million on the same terms and the SAFE investors together are in line for roughly 20% at that point. The first investor’s 5% is included.
Those percentages are estimates. A low enough price in the next financing can give the SAFE investors more shares on conversion. The new shares the company sells in that financing will dilute the founders and the SAFE investors alike.
What would earn a higher cap?
Your cofounder might have a good answer. The first $250,000 pays for a pilot. If the customer signs an annual contract, you think you can raise the remaining $750,000 at a $7.5 million post-money cap. On the same assumptions, those later checks would account for roughly 10%. Add the first investor’s 5% and the whole raise comes to about 15%.
That five-point difference depends on two things. The customer has to sign before you need the cash, and another investor has to agree the contract is worth a higher cap. If payroll comes due first, you may be back in the market with the same product and less time.
I’d put the question to both founders while the first SAFE is still unsigned. If the other $750,000 arrived tomorrow at the same $5 million cap, would you take it?
If you would, you know what you’re willing to sell to fund the plan. If you wouldn’t, this is a good time to revisit the cap, the amount you need, or what the first check can buy you.